Thursday, March 5, 2020

Childhood Horrors

No photo description available.
In fourth grade a friend told me that he was immortal. Claiming to be a demigod or wizard or alien in a highly realistic human suit had been a day-to-day occurrence with kids I’d known since Kindergarten, so by then I was more or less over it. At the time I hardly even listened to his rationale, though some part of it stuck with me, because I still remember it today: “My Dad hurts me so bad sometimes. Anyone else would have died over and over, but I didn’t, so there must be something special about me.”
Just before I moved to Minnesota I went to a fantasy play-acting camp with a paramilitary bent, where we learned to march in formation and fight with foam swords, while our councilors did acrobatic stunt shows fighting pretend monsters with real weapons. There was one kid I got to know pretty well who seemed to get special treatment: he got to hold a real mace once, even though he was barely strong enough to hold it, and the head-councilor let him talk to an ent in a vital scene for the plot of the summer, while the rest of us just sat around and watched. Once I asked him why he got to do all this cool stuff, and he just kicked at the dirt and said he didn’t know. I assumed he was just ashamed that his billionaire parents had bribed him into special privileges. And maybe that is really what happened. But he was bone-thin and entirely bald, so there’s another option too.

Maybe the first time I got a glimpse of this childhood horror, the kind that doesn’t really hit until you look back on it years later, was when my Dad took me to volunteer at our church’s evacuee shelter when Hurricane Ike hit Texas. But there wasn’t much a little kid like me could do to help, so instead I spent the morning playing with this boy. I don’t remember what we did, but we must have had a lot of fun, because when he went missing, I spent the entire afternoon running around looking for him. Eventually I found him in the quarters where the evacuees slept: a dim room full of snoring men and slowly leaking airbeds. The boy spoke to a man, probably his father, in hushed and worried Spanish. I knew I shouldn’t be there, so I left before they could see me. 

That was the only one of these examples in which I noticed the real despair of the situation in the moment. I didn’t put the pieces together just then, didn’t realize that their home might have been destroyed or they might have lost a family member in the storm. But I knew that something sad had happened, more sad than I could really comprehend, so I ran away scared.

For the most part, though, I was an oblivious kid. I thought child abuse meant spanking, couldn’t imagine someone my own age could get cancer, and assumed that all the families staying at our church would have somewhere else to live once the storm blew past. Probably that’s a good thing: the vast majority of my childhood life I was so far from tragedy that when I did see it, I didn’t recognize it. But I still can’t help but feel guilty. What really gets me is my friend who thought he was immortal: if I’d really listened to him and asked a few questions, I could’ve told an adult, and maybe they could’ve helped somehow. I’m not so sure I could’ve helped the other two, cancer and hurricanes are beyond my power to stop, and their problems are a little bit more ambiguous. Maybe the kid at camp just happened to be bald, skinny, and rich. Maybe the kid at the shelter’s Dad was talking to him about something different, and really they were safe and fine and well-insured. But at least I could’ve been a little bit more observant, and offered whatever sympathy and comfort a kid can.

But maybe I picked up on more than I’m giving myself credit for. From what I’ve seen, kids notice a lot more than most adults believe; they just can’t explain what they see, or choose not to. I could see myself seeing the darkness in all three of these stories, but ignoring it, then intentionally forgetting, because I wasn’t ready for it. After all, there was never a revelation moment when I exclaimed to myself, “Oh wow, that kid must have been going through so much!” It feels like I’ve always known, which means either I came to terms with it subconsciously, or I really did always know.


For the most part, I don’t beat myself up for not doing more. However I feel about it, though, they’re all in the past now, there’s nothing to be done. But even though I was never a kid to notice pain in my peers and heal it, that’s not impossible, and it’s beautiful when it happens. At my job working with second graders last summer, I saw kids hugging and comforting each other the day after some tragedy hit. I’m not saying that we should leave it up to kids to be each others’ therapists, or expect them to always know how to help one another. But it does happen sometimes, and it’s beautiful.

Thursday, February 27, 2020

Long Races


There were a lot of interesting characters at the New York State Summer Writer’s Institute, among them a power-lifter and hammer-thrower from Princeton, who explained one night, after the visiting poet’s reading, that weight lifting was the greatest sport there is. People don’t make these kinds of unqualified claims anymore; they make timider arguments, like that weight lifting is a very good sport, or that weight lifting offers something special to certain people. But, being the sort of the bold person you’d expect a Princeton power lifter to be, she went all in and explained why lifting was unequivocally the greatest of all athletic competitions. Apparently, it’s all about how in one simple movement, one single moment, your muscles endure a level of pain and expel a level of energy that they can’t and won’t anywhere else There’s no strategy, no fanfare, nothing but strength presented as simply as possible.

As you might expect, I didn’t like hearing that the apotheosis of all athleticism was something I could hardly do. (At the time, my squat record was 60 pounds. My all-time max now is 100, which is hardly a warmup for her.) Especially as a track athlete, where running 100 meters can score you as many points as running 10,000, I’ve always believed in a certain equality of athletics, that people tend to develop what they’re naturally good at and ignore what they’re not. Some sports take different kinds of effort than others, some offer more acclaim, but they all pose similar challenges, and what you do is more a matter of biology than choice. Now that I think of it, though, this sort of thinking might be more of a cop-out than anything else. People often treat me as something of a masochist when I tell them my favorite race is the 10k, but when they ask me why, I always say that it’s simply what I’m built for, that I don’t have the fast-twitch muscles you need for shorter races. I do well in it so I like it. Simple as that.

But maybe I could use some of the Princeton hammer-thrower’s uncut confidence. Maybe I should argue that the longest race is always the best; not the one that I’m built for or the one I find least offensive, but objectively the best. Because in two days I’ll be racing the 5k for the indoor conference championship, and the 3k the day after that, the two longest races in indoors, and more than anything, it’s because I love them.

When the gun goes off in any short race, every nerve in your body has to scream “Go!” That’s a thrill, I guess, but there’s a different, more interesting feeling at the start of the long race. You still have that primal urge to surge ahead, but instead of obeying it you have to wrangle it, use it, keep it under control. To race well, the front spot has to be something you desperately want, but can’t take, even though it’s open. Because anyone could take that spot. Just about everyone has, sometime in middle school, before you’d learned the unwritten rules of human endurance. That time in middle school you probably dropped out of the race, maybe cried, definitely threw up. So you have to stay restrained and keep the pace, hoping that everyone in front of you has made a mistake and gone out too fast, and that you’ll be rewarded later. And you will, if you keep running the same pace even as your body fails, even as each straightaway stretches longer than the one before. People will wear out and fall behind if you keep a consistent pace. But it takes a long time for that to happen (a 10k takes about half an hour to finish), so, unlike most other races, you have time to think. You have time to get used to your opponents’ backsides, memorize their tattoos and analyze their stride and wonder how long it’ll be before they break and you pass them. Sometimes they pass you back, and it goes back and forth like that, maybe for the entire race, so by the end of it you feel like you have a sort of grudging respect for one another, even though you haven’t exchanged a single word (unless sharp breaths and exhausted groans count). That can’t happen in other races, they just go too fast. But the long races aren’t really races at all; they’re more like wars of attrition, and the best you can do is keep up the pace and wait for everyone else to shut down. At least, until the second or third lap from the end, when everyone forgets about pacing or waiting and burns energy they don’t have trying to get ahead. It becomes sort of like a cruel mirror of the first lap: you feel like you should be able to take the lead, everyone is screaming for you to do just that, but all the power between your bones is sucked dry and all you can do is keep flailing forward, hoping that maybe a second wind will catch you. 


Is that a reason why long races are the best? I don’t know. It doesn’t have a thesis statement like the Princeton hammer thrower did, and I don’t have her succinctness either, so in a lot of ways this blog post is worse than her off-the-cuff comment three years ago. But I hope that at least I described that they mean something. Maybe I don't have the confidence to say that they're the best, but they're at least my favorite.

Thursday, February 20, 2020

Heavenly Boredom


Today my girlfriend and I were watching an episode of The Good Place and she noticed me suddenly tense up at a seemingly innocuous scene. I won’t go into the details since the show is very easily spoiled, but since the entire series is about the afterlife, I think it’s reasonable to reveal that this episode was about a basic problem with heaven: wouldn’t it get boring after a while? I mean, with an infinite amount of time and a finite human imagination or attention span, it would have to get old eventually. The promise that there will be no pain, no fear, no uncertainty basically erases any reason to care about the world. It’s a problem that’s been bugging me since third grade, when I waited so long for summer vacation, then a week after it started I woke up with all the time in the world and nothing to do with it. It probably seems reductive to compare the infinite glory of God’s Almighty Kingdom to an elementary schooler getting bored of summer break, but I’ve never really been able to separate the two.

This complaint about heaven is historically rather new, actually. Last year, when I was visiting my sister in New York, we went to the Met museum, where we found a medieval painting of heaven and hell (pictured above). I said that hell looked a whole lot cooler than heaven, thinking that I was making a very original insight. I mean, yes, hell was mostly comprised of naked corpses being skewered by demons, while everyone in heaven had fully clothed and intact bodies. But at least hell had emotion and color, while heaven was just a couple dozen bearded men in robes, standing with perfect posture and blank expressions. My sister explained that she’d actually read a paper on the subject (which I’d name-drop here, if I remembered it) about how heaven was so much more appealing in the past because people back then valued order and stability so much more than we do now. After all, back then even the kings and queens couldn’t stop disease or miscarriages from claiming their children, while most of the population suffered daily toil and drudgery. A world with no work or pain seemed like an improvement, and they saw no reason to see past that. Meanwhile, us affluent people have running water, heat and cooling, light at any time of the day, and so much entertainment that our biggest problem is usually there being too much to keep up with. We’ve made what most people throughout history would call a heaven, and we still want something more.

In The Good Place, the characters decide that, just like life on earth is meaningful because it ends, an ideal heaven must end, that bliss has no meaning if it’s eternal. That’s why this episode got me so scared: they’d laid out so many of the same worries I’d had about heaven, then answered them by saying that the afterlife can’t really be a full afterlife, that even it needs death to be worthwhile. And, as I’ve said before on this blog, I’m terrified of any kind of permanent death. The idea that I won’t be able to escape it, that I can’t be happy without it looming over me, is enough to tighten every muscle in my body just upon hearing.

The Good Place misdiagnosis the problem with heaven, though. Actions on earth don’t have meaning because one day we’ll die forever. Whenever I try thinking that way it makes it seem as though nothing we do on earth is meaningful because it will all come to nothing in thousands of years. Actions have meaning because we don’t know if we’ll succeed or fail, if our lives and accomplishments will endure or not. Faith, or the lack thereof, is nothing but a hope or theory; no matter what we claim, I think deep down everyone is some shade of agnostic. Looking at it this way, eternal life and permanent death seem almost identical: an eternity of certainty.


All of this probably sounds very anti-Christian, and sometimes I question if that’s still a good descriptor of me, given my doubts. But one thing I love about the Episcopal church is how it embraces these contradictions and paradoxes and makes them part of our very creed. A key tenant is the mystery of faith: that God is ultimately unknowable, no matter how deep your faith. I can’t speak with certainty, but I think that after we die, we won’t understand or know everything. We won’t escape pain or worry. We won’t even know for sure that this lasts forever. But we’ll maintain the same faith that we had on earth, and hope to hell that it does.

Thursday, February 13, 2020

Love


(Pictured above: My girlfriend Mica, a very talented artist, drew a profile view of me, which turned out pretty damn great. Then she asked me to do the same. I only ever draw stick figures and monsters, so my version of her came out a little bit as both. In real life she’s beautiful.)

I read a study once that something like 98% of American movies are about romance, or at least have some sort of sub-plot. It makes sense, then, that I’ve been looking forward to falling in love for as long as I can remember. Love seemed like something inevitable that would happen later on when I was a kid, like getting a job or dying. I never really explored dating in elementary school, mostly because I was with the same group of seven kids from Kindergarten through sixth grade, so we were all practically siblings. Part of why I looked forward to moving to a larger middle school in seventh grade was that I might finally have a chance to get a girlfriend. But middle school passed by, then high school, and most of college without anything more serious than asking someone to a dance. As I saw my friends pair up and profess love, I felt profoundly left out. There were so many milestones I hadn’t passed, not so much sexual stuff (I’d learned that “virgin” was something other than an epithet for Mary, Mother of Christ as recently as eighth grade, so even in my high school I wasn’t really in that mindset*), but so many cultural markers of what it meant to become and adult and form a real, powerful relationship with another person.

Things changed when I went to Florida with the track team last year. It felt like one of those books where a kid gets thrown into a new world: when I fell asleep on the bus there was snow on the ground, and when I woke up it was eighty degrees and the roads were lined with jungle plants I thought only existed in prehistoric times. In that different world, the bad luck I’d been locked into changed in an instant: Mica, a young woman on the team who I’d always thought was pretty but never had the courage to talk to, sat down next to me and started talking to me. As soon as we found out we were both writers, we started talking about our work and were nearly inseparable for the rest of the trip**. We went to a bookstore together and walked up and down the shelves, pointing out different things we’d read. On the bus ride back she sang selections from Les Miserables with some friends on the women’s team for me and I called a number on a billboard asking “Want to Talk About God?” and asked the guy on the other end of the line if I could have 800 concubines like King Solomon to prove to her that I wasn’t a fundamentalist. She was (and is) witty and incisive, brilliant and inventive, beautiful, graceful, bold enough to challenge me when I’m wrong but kind and supportive all the same. Less than a month after getting back we were dating.

I’d daydreamed about the stages of a relationship since middle school: first time holding hands, first kiss, first dance at a party, first date, changing your Facebook relationship status.
Through high school and into college, as they seemed less likely to ever happen, these milestones haunted me even as I fantasized about them. Once I met Mica, they all passed so quickly and seemed nearly weightless. It’s not that I didn’t enjoy them, but they didn’t have the same force I thought they would. It wasn’t the benchmark that mattered anymore, but who I was doing it with. I didn’t love Mica because she bumped up my score on some life-goal tally. I loved her (and love her) because she laughs when I overpronounce my T’s and gives me honest sentence-by-sentence feedback on all my stories and makes a big deal about using her special wash on my face to get the dead skin off and sometimes breaks out singing something I can’t understand in Spanish and hundreds or thousands or countless other things, little and big, that make her Mica, my beloved.

Sometimes I can’t believe how much time I wasted, desperately wanting something that didn’t turn out to be important. When I thought of myself with a girlfriend, I didn’t see her as a person so much as a solution to my loneliness and anxiety and feeling of failure. But love is so much more than just a solution: it’s its own being, its own creation, something beautiful and indescribable and unique to everyone who feels it. So much of life would have been so much easier if I could’ve assured my past self not to worry, that it would all turn out okay eventually. But my past self probably wouldn’t’ve believed me, at least not until he met Mica.
____________________
* Of course, I heard about non-Mary people referred to as virgins before, but I always thought it designated them as Mary like: kind, devout, and courageous. In middle school some boys, who I only later realized were bullying me, asked me if I was a virgin and I said, “I hope to be some day, but I don’t think I’m there yet.” At some point I saw a poster for the movie “The 40-Year-Old Virgin” and decided that it was a raunchy, iconoclastic comedy in which Steve Carrel played a middle-aged atheist whose life is turned upside down when he finds himself pregnant with Jesus for the Second Coming. In conclusion, my childhood was defined by both misinformation and boundless unwarranted confidence that I had everything figured out.

** She actually got to know me pretty well from reading this very blog! Pretty meta, huh?

Thursday, January 30, 2020

Iowa Caucuses and Why I'm With Warren


U. S. government is weird. On the most basic level, a democratic republic with checks and balances between three branches of the government designed to write, enforce, and interpret laws, with parallel structures on the state and national level, seems like an excellent and intuitive system. But when you get into the fine details, everything suddenly seems arbitrary and kind of stupid. For example, who the hell decided to have goddamn Iowa be the first caucus state? How on earth does it make any sense for candidates to pander to some mostly-white, mostly-empty state from November to February of election years, then forgot about us as soon as the votes come in?

All the same, as little sense as it makes, Iowa is the first caucus state, which means that I’ll have a wildly disproportionate power in choosing the Democratic candidate this Monday. The last few months I’ve seen student advocates handing out flyers every time I walk into the dining hall and sat through fifteen-second campaign ads every time I watch a video on YouTube. I even had the chance to see Elizabeth Warren and Beto O’Rourke live the past couple months. And, since I have this electoral power I didn’t earn and don’t really need, I figure I might as well use it to advocate for my chosen candidate, Elizabeth Warren.

My girlfriend sometimes teases me that I only like her because I’m studying to be a public school teacher, and she made a pretty explicit effort to pander to my field at her campaign rally. And really, that is a large part of it, not just that she’s a defender of teachers, but she seems to speak and act for actual citizens. Of course, being on the side of the people is something almost every candidate claims, but Warren makes the claim more coherently and effectively than any other politician I have ever seen. Her “two cent tax” on those with over fifty million dollars strips away the lie that taxing the wealthy hurts all of us, and reveals how much the push against taxation is motivated by greed. Bernie aims for something similar with his railing against millionaires and billionaires, but Warren combines rhetoric and policy in a much more elegant way that I think can reach voters more effectively.

That focus on policy is another reason I like Warren. All the candidates have a nuanced policy, but Warren has a long record of dealing thoroughly and specifically with the details of what needs to be done. I especially like how she admits the possibility of working with an uncooperative house and senate, and has a specific list of plans for how a president can enact progressive policy on her own. A common comeback is that her policy, though detailed, is too extreme to work. But I’d argue healthcare for all, for example, is neither unattainable (it works for most other industrialized countries, and with much lower costs) nor frivolous (people dying from preventable conditions in the richest country on earth is simply unacceptable).

Of course, extremely progressive ideas aren’t exclusive to Warren, and many people on the Grinnell campus prefer Bernie Sander simply because, if you chart their political leanings, Bernie comes out the furthest left. But I find Warren’s ideas much more clearly articulated in her speeches and debates, and she has a better history of working with people to achieve progressive aims, given that Bernie refused to identify with the democratic party in the senate. 

And I won’t deny that Warren’s gender is important, and one of the reasons why I’m voting for her. Donald Trump’s campaign and election sent the message that sexism, misogyny, and outright rape are acceptable, and the reaction from alt-right communities and the rise in hate crime after his election show that our politicians have real effects on our communities. This isn’t just an abstract population statistic, it’s an immediate effect: the day after Donald Trump’s election, men in pick-up trucks drove through campus harassing students of color and women. Electing Elizabeth Warren wouldn’t extinguish sexism immediately, but it would be a strong symbolic victory with positive effects on how people in our country view women. And it’s not impossible either: with a much weaker platform and less enthusiastic support, a woman still won the popular election in 2016. Donald Trump is the president, but America chose Hillary Clinton.


As passionately as I support Elizabeth Warren, all of the candidates have their strengths. I would love to see Pete Buttigieg provide the world with a progressive Christian icon, and America’s first gay president would be a huge step forward. Andrew Yang’s insistence that disabled people should not be valued for their labor but their status as human beings is a powerful truth that needs to be spread. Bernie Sanders would implement many of the same badly needed reforms as Elizabeth Warren. Even Joe Biden, probably my last choice, would still move the country in the right direction, and the progressive energy of this campaign season will mean he’ll do it with more vigor than if he won the nomination easily. I’ll happily vote for any of them come election season. But even if any of them would be a good choice, the question is who is the best, and I’ll gladly answer Elizabeth Warren come Monday.

Thursday, January 23, 2020

Leaving Inklette


Two years ago I wrote a post where I recommended that every new writer, as a rule, should work at a literary magazine. I still believe that, and I still consider myself a new writer (since I plan to keep this up for my whole life, being at it for five to six years still puts me well in the beginner category), but despite all that I’m breaking my own rule and leaving the magazine where I’ve worked the past five years. The reason is simple: I’m getting busier, taking on more writing projects, and I don’t want to keep my name on the masthead unless I’m an actively contributing member, which I can’t be anymore. But it still hurts to let go of the literary community that I devoted so many hours to and made so many friends on. So I’m going to spend this week’s post looking back on my time as part of it.

Before I joined Inklette, I didn’t think that there were really all that many real writers. There were hordes bright-eyed high schoolers and bored adults working at night and weekends on novels that would never make it beyond a few beta readers, of course, but the only a few people, as lucky and rare as lottery winners, actually ever got published. Joining Inklette was my introduction to the enormous ecosystem of how publishing actually operates, with millions of stories searching for publication in thousands of little magazines like us, which might gain traction and win contests and send the authors flying up to big name awards and publishers.

My job as an editor was a lot like a miner, or maybe it’s more accurate to say scavenger. We’d get a lot of submissions each issue, sometimes as many as five hundred, and read through each one, looking for promise. Even if you aren’t super picky with your reading and overlook grammar and spelling errors, it isn’t hard to sort through them. Most are simply poorly written, the sentences too simple or overloaded with adjectives, the stories and characters predictable or random, it’s easy enough to list why the story doesn’t work in two sentences. But every so often, there was a story that just simply worked. It’s hard to explain what exactly worked about them. They weren’t all typo-free, they didn’t all have well-rounded characters or some particular kind of elegance in the writing. Read through our issues, and you’ll see that there isn’t any unifying theme between all the stories. Not all of them are even stories, strictly speaking. The best way I can describe it is to say that the author promised something in the first few sentences, and after a page or so you learned to trust that promise, that you weren’t going to be let down, and you let yourself get swept along in the ride. It’s an odd feeling, reading a story that might be a winner: you want to be wise and discerning and objective, and so you try your best to mentally note weak phrases and spots for improvement, but another part of you really wants to like it, to trust it, and those two critical urges play off one another until some kind of breaking point when it works or it doesn’t, and if it does then you let the momentum rush you to the end.


But oddly, when I think back to those nights in the library, reading through submission after submission after submission, I don’t remember much about which ones we ended up rejecting or accepting. What sticks in my mind is that moment when I wasn’t sure if I liked it or not yet, when I weighed this weak characterization against that wonderful sentence and read on, waiting to see how it developed. That was the real joy of the appraisal, I think. Maybe it doesn’t make much sense, but it felt worth writing about.

Thursday, January 16, 2020

Defense of Slacking

In the winter of my junior year of high school, all student-athletes got out of class to see some sort of “Excellence Assembly.” It turned out to be something like a TED-Talk, except the presenter appeared to have a passionate and personal hatred for each and every one of us. His speech jumped wildly between topics, veering from drug use to social media to nutrition to sleep to exercise, but on each point he had a consistent message: there was a right and a wrong way to do these things, and we were all doing it the wrong way. He personified the right way as some U.S. Marines that he’d known, who he described as perfect human machines who rarely talked and never laughed and always marched in perfect formation.

In case it isn’t clear, I despised this presentation, and as soon as it let out I wrote an editorial response that I planned to send to the student newspaper. I don’t have it saved anywhere (though, given my writing at the time, I bet it was hardly more intelligent than the presentation itself), but I still remember the last line: “After all, someone has to defend having a good time.”

In the end, I decided not to try to publish it for two reasons. First, if anyone who didn’t know me read it, they’d dismiss it as another lazy kid trying to find an excuse to be lazy (“Teenager DislikesBeing Told What to Do” is hardly headline news). And, second, anyone who did know me would know that I was the last person to defend having a good time. I hardly ever missed a day of cross country practice, never turned an assignment in late, and my idea of a splurge was to push my bedtime back to 10:00 and watch two episodes of The Simpsons in the evening instead of just one. Not to mention that due to my OCD (undiagnosed at the time, but still very much present), I was probably even more obsessed with doing things the right way than the presenter, though my right way mostly focused on the number thirteen in some way.

But an important factor of my OCD is that it only affects what I do. Sure, I’ll be certain something terrible will happen if I stop reading a book on page thirteen, but I don’t care if other people do what they will with that number. But there are a lot of people like that TED-Talker who can’t stand other people doing things the wrong way, however trivial the difference between right and wrong is. You run into these kinds of people often in schools: class picture photographers who spend an hour making sure everyone has the same expression and proper posture, choir directors who demand a hyper-specific dress code, coaches who publicly shame anyone doing the drills wrong. What’s worst is when these people in charge try to be enthusiastic about their strict and arbitrary rules, those teachers who explain the proper way to write a cursive G with a huge smile on their face, not because of any use this letter has, but because the pointless act of writing a cursive G is somehow supposed to be fun. There’s actually a fairly popular and respected teaching technique called behaviorism that is essentially this: embracing obedience as a virtue, rewarding the right behaviors and punishing the wrong ones, while leaving the student with no uncontrolled choices.

OCD aside, it’s strange that I get so mad at people who value obedience. After all, I want to be a teacher, and even if I’m not a full-on behaviorist, no one can run an effective classroom without some emphasis on obedience. I guess it’s the arbitrariness that frustrates me, how the rules are supposed to sit invincibly once they’re laid down. But that arbitrariness is necessary sometimes. I ran into that problem teaching basic literacy skills to elementary schoolers this summer. Capital letters and silent e’s seem perfectly natural to me, but I’ve seen firsthand how much students despise constant correction, even if it is the only way to learn. There’s no way to make it not arbitrary either: I love it, but I have to admit that English writing makes no sense at all.

As useful as obedience is, I think that it’s overused, especially in schools. Having a little room for natural deviation or a little time for slacking off is a necessary resource for sanity. When possible, teachers should enforce the least strict version of the rules, or at least explain why it exists in the first place. I get that it’s probably premature to lay down my laws for teaching before actually doing it on my own yet, but maybe it’s best for me to lay it down now, before life as a teacher grinds away at me too much. After a few years of not being a student, I might be in danger of forgetting what it’s like to be bossed around all day, and I never want to end up like the irate TED-Talker.